The WoD Classic Question

"Will we get Warlords of Draenor Classic?" is not a question I thought I would ever be asking myself ten years ago. Hell, I didn't think we'd ever be asking it five years ago. WoW Classic transitioning into Burning Crusade Classic seemed natural. Following that up with Wrath Classic was a no-brainer. Cataclysm Classic already raised some eyebrows, because can you really call any expansion that takes place after the destruction of the old world "classic"? Anyone having any interest in MoP Classic seemed even more unlikely considering the weak reception MoP had during its first run, not to mention that retail had just had the Mists of Pandaria Remix event. And yet here we are, wondering whether Warlords of Draenor Classic will be next.

I've tried to compile a list of factual pros and cons for why things could go either way:

Yes, we will get WoD Classic:

• It's a relatively low effort option. Not no effort, as it's still work to reinstate the way WoD worked in the modern Classic client, but at least Blizzard wouldn't need to expend any creative energy on coming up with anything new.
• There are still hundreds of thousands of players playing on the progressive Classic realms, numbers that many smaller MMOs would be envious of. You don't hear about them much, but we can see from activity data that they exist and are playing, which they presumably wouldn't do if they weren't enjoying themselves. MoP Classic as a whole seems to be a prime example of a quiet majority that just gets on with things and that you never hear about because they are simply content. That should be enough incentive for Blizzard to keep the good times (and people's subscriptions) rolling.
• We know that Blizzard is at least considering WoD Classic, because as part of a survey sent out around the middle of last year, they asked players where they'd want go play after MoP Classic ends. WoD Classic was one of the options, with some of the possible alternatives being a merge into retail, a MoP era realm or a transition back into a previous expansion (no idea how that would even work).

No, we won't get WoD Classic:

• From the outside, it would be a bad look. WoD is still considered one of WoW's worst expansions. (No longer the worst thanks to Shadowlands, but definitely in the bottom three.) While there is an audience that would like to revisit it for sure, the more outspoken parts of the WoW community all look down on the progressive Classic servers at this point. Most of the Classic community no longer considers them "classic enough", while they are obviously still more than a decade removed from retail as well. Cataclysm Classic already got a pretty lukewarm reception at BlizzCon 2023; I can't imagine anyone cheering for a WoD Classic if it was to be announced at BlizzCon this year. The devs must know that it would be terrible PR to potentially announce a Classic expansion and get booed, so with that in mind, they shouldn't do it. (If they go ahead with it, the announcement better be low-key and they damn well need to make sure that there'll be some other major Classic news to overshadow it.)
• While the old world has already been replaced with the Cataclysm revamp in Cata Classic, at least MoP Classic still has the old character models, right? WoD Classic would take another step closer towards retail by introducing the new character models (if we want to stay in sync with how things went during the original run). The closer the two versions get in terms of features, the less it feels like there's a point to still having this separate progression branch.
• Even if there's still a significant number of people playing MoP Classic, it's undeniably a branch of Classic that's in decline. New or returning players interested in Classic are far more likely to want to check out the anniversary servers rather than grind through 85 levels of an already disjointed levelling experience to start adventuring in Pandaland, and this is only going to get worse if more levels get added. On the dev side, Blizzard also seems to have cut back on the amount of attention they've given progressive Classic, and after the impeccably built original Classic launched in 2019, each subsequent expansion has been buggier and buggier. There was a post on the Wow subreddit three days ago about how Throne of Thunder in MoP Classic has been out for three months and still almost every single boss in there is bugged in some way.
• I know I cited last year's survey in the "yes" column already, but to be honest, you could also interpret it as a sign pointing towards no, considering that the relevant poll question had seven different options, only one of which was WoD Classic, and even that one said "if it becomes available" - Blizzard did not want to lock themselves into going down that route!

---

I think there are compelling arguments for either course of action at this point, and I suspect that what will tip the scales for Blizzard will depend a lot on their internal metrics for MoP Classic, including the results of that survey.

Personally, I would actually check out WoD Classic on my hunter if it does come out, simply because WoD is one of those expansions I didn't play back in the day and going back to do some of the content in retail just hasn't been the same. It's definitely more insightful and authentic to do either a Classic or a Remix run. I don't think I'd play it for long, but I'd at least take a look.

On the other hand, I can't say that I'd be sad if they decided to call it quits on the progression servers at this point either, and I would also be fine with my hunter being merged into my retail character stable (or even going back in time to a previous version of Classic I guess, if that somehow becomes a thing).